Day by day, optical communication systems are increasing their range and capacity. The first commercial systems of 40 Gbit/s have already been launched, although transmissions of 160 Gbit/s per channel and even higher have been demonstrated in various trials. Measuring the quality of high-speed signals requires a range of high-performance instrumentation, which represents a significant financial investment. This includes laboratory equipment such as digital optical oscilloscopes, PRBS generators and error rate meters, optical spectrum analyzers, pulse autocorrelators, frame and protocol analyzers, and more. This article will focus on BER meters and the fundamentals associated with their measurement.


Error Rate Meters.
Error rate meters are primarily used to determine the Bit Error Rate (BER) of an optical communication link. This measurement is performed by injecting a pseudorandom sequence (PRBS) into the optical transmitter, and then measuring the number of errors that occurred in the system at the optical receiver. Currently, these devices achieve bit rates of up to 40 Gbit/s and typically include optical input/output interfaces. Complete solutions are commercially available, encompassing a range of components such as an electronic PRBS generator, an electronic error rate meter, an optical transmitter consisting of a laser and external modulator, multiplexers/demuxes, an optical receiver, a clock recovery circuit, and more.
Options from multiple manufacturers are available on the market.

Optical Networks102-1 Figures 1 and 2 show two examples of this type of instrumentation. The first is the Agilent ParBERT 45G, which allows the generation of OC-768 signals (40 Gbit/s) and BER measurement on optical systems and devices in general. It is a highly flexible platform that can be configured via software for any specific measurement need. New features include the generation of NRZ, RZ, and RZ-CS signals, recirculating loop measurements using signal bursts, configuration of thresholds and sampling points, clock recovery of data, and more. The second instrument is the SHF 50G BERT. This is a compact and scalable solution, also software-configurable, that allows for the addition of modules as needed (optical transmitters/receivers, clock recovery, etc.). It provides bit rates from 6 to 50 Gbit/s with low jitter (< 500 fs). New features include the option of adding a DPSK optical receiver. Additionally, and without going into detail, it is recommended to also consult the 48 Gbit/s test systems from Anritsu (model ME7780A) and Rohde & Schwarz (model D3691/D3692/D3693), which offer similar capabilities and performance to those previously mentioned.

 

Optical-networks-102-2Fundamentals of BER Measurement
Bit errors result from incorrect decisions made by the receiver circuit due to the presence of noise in the digital signal. Considering two-level optical intensity modulation (OOK, on-off keying) and Gaussian noise, the bit error rate (BER)

It is defined as:

Formula-102-11

Formula-102-1-1

where the meaning of each of the variables is represented schematically in Figure 3.
The optimal decision threshold is the one that provides the minimum BER,

given by:

Formula-102-2Formula-102-1where Q represents a measure of signal quality, which is defined as:


Formula-102-3This Q factor is commonly known as the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in units of voltage or current. In reality, it can be defined even when the noise is not Gaussian, although in the former case there is a direct relationship between BER and Q.
Traditionally, BER is measured as a function of SNR. This is the case for wireless or coaxial cable systems, where the dominant noise contributions may not be located in the receiver (source or channel noise), and the SNR is usually proportional to Q. In contrast, in the case of optical systems, BER is measured as a function of the average received optical power, or Prec. Assuming that the dominant noise is the receiver's thermal noise and that the digital signal extinction ratio is high, then the Q factor is proportional to Prec, and the SNR in dB is proportional to Prec in dBm.
BER measurements begin with a back-to-back configuration, which allows for the independent characterization of the receiving device's quality. To do this, the transmitter is connected directly to the receiver via a variable optical attenuator, as shown in Figure 4(a). In this way, and given that the quality of the transmitted signal is sufficiently good, the BER measurements refer only to the performance of the optical receiver. For each optical attenuation value (corresponding to a Prec value), the optimal decision threshold is set, and the BER is measured. The receiver's sensitivity is defined as the Prec value for which a BER of 10⁻⁹, 10⁻¹⁰, or 10⁻¹² is obtained. The system under test is then inserted, as shown in Figure 4(b), and the measurements are repeated. If the system introduces noise or any type of degradation that modifies the signal, these effects will be reflected in the BER curve. It is important to note that any type of system attenuation will not, in itself, degrade the BER, since the BER is represented as a function of Prec. However, attenuation followed by a process that adds noise (for example, an optical amplifier) ​​will cause a reduction in the Q factor and therefore an increase in the error rate. That is, a degradation of the BER curve.

Optical-networks-102-3Types of degradation

In general, BER results are very helpful in determining the type of degradation occurring in the system and identifying its physical origin. We will now discuss some examples. The extinction ratio (ER) of an optical OOK signal is defined as the ratio of the average optical powers of levels '1' and '0'. In the ideal case, this is equal to infinity, since the power of level '0' should be zero. ER degradation manifests in the BER curve as a shift towards higher powers, as shown in Figure 5(a). In this case, the power penalty, defined as the dB degradation of the receiver's sensitivity, can be calculated using:

Formula-102-4

where r = P0/P1, P0 and P1 being the average optical powers of levels '0' and '1', respectively. For example, for an ER given by r = 0.1 (10 dB), there is a power penalty of 0.87 dB.
Similarly, ASE noise from the optical amplifiers of a link also contributes to degrading the BER curves. On the one hand, the average ASE noise power increases the '0' level, resulting in ER degradation and a shift in the BER curve. On the other hand, this ASE noise degrades the eye pattern, so an increase in received optical power does not improve signal quality. The result is the appearance of a background BER below which it is impossible to reduce the signal. This effect is shown in Figure 5(b).


Optical-networks-102-4Finally, intersymbol interference (ISI) also causes BER degradation (power penalty and/or the appearance of a BER background). This can be due to multiple causes (chromatic dispersion, nonlinearities, etc.), although BER curve analysis alone is insufficient to identify the nature of the problem, and other measurements such as eye diagrams are required. In this case, ISI can be identified by the BER curve's dependence on the PRBS pattern. To do this, comparative measurements should be made with PRBS patterns from 27-1 to 231-1, and even with the "0101..." pattern.

'

 

Optical-networks-102-5Validity of the Measurements:
Given that BER has a clear statistical component, it is necessary to ensure a certain level of confidence in the measurements. The following expression can be used as a statistical estimator:
where ne is the number of errors and Nb is the total number of bits (sufficiently large). Assuming independent errors, the statistical distribution is binomial. With this data, to ensure a 95% confidence level, a total of 100 errors need to be observed. This is equivalent to approximately 3 seconds at 40 Gbit/s for 10¹¹ bits (BER = 10⁻⁹) and approximately 7 hours for 10¹⁵ bits (BER = 10⁻¹²).
Unfortunately, some systems exhibit correlated errors, the most common case being the appearance of error bursts caused by some type of external fluctuation. That is, a fairly low error rate is observed for a long period of time and then suddenly increases considerably as a result of an error burst. In these cases, to ensure the measurement results are reliable, it's necessary to isolate the cause of the burst and measure the BER during the burst-free period. Alternatively, a sufficiently long time interval can be used to encompass a statistically significant number of error bursts. Measuring equipment typically includes error interval counters to aid in this process.
In short, BER measurements require a methodical approach to ensure accuracy. Fortunately, modern measuring equipment offers great versatility and a wide range of electrical and optical connection options and interfaces, simplifying the design and monitoring of optical communication systems and networks.

 

More information or a quote

 

Francisco Ramos Pascual. PhD in Telecommunications Engineering

Full Professor at the Polytechnic University of Valencia